TechAILatest.newsTrackers
AI Policy & Regulation / Copyright

OpenAI loses Ontario appeal, so Canadian news publishers' copyright lawsuit can go ahead

The Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed OpenAI's appeal on 13 November 2026, so the copyright suit by Canadian news publishers can proceed in Ontario.

By Emre A.Published

Abstract illustration of the columns of a public institutionTech AI Latest
Illustration of the columns of a public institution, made by Tech AI Latest for this story. Illustration: Tech AI Latest (Original illustration)

The Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed OpenAI's appeal on 13 November 2026, upholding a lower court ruling that Ontario courts have jurisdiction over the copyright lawsuit filed by Canadian news publishers including the Toronto Star, Postmedia, The Globe and Mail, The Canadian Press and CBC/Radio-Canada. The publishers allege OpenAI used their journalism to train ChatGPT without permission or payment. OpenAI had argued the case belonged in a US court. The merits are still undecided.

Key facts

  • Decided: 13 November 2026 by the Court of Appeal for Ontario (court decisions)
  • Outcome: OpenAI's appeal dismissed; the lawsuit can proceed in Ontario
  • Plaintiffs: Toronto Star, Metroland Media, Postmedia, PNI Maritimes, The Globe and Mail, The Canadian Press, CBC/Radio-Canada
  • OpenAI's argument: the case should be heard in the United States
  • Lower court: Ontario Superior Court of Justice, 2025 ONSC 6217
  • Not stated: a trial date or any ruling on whether training was lawful

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed OpenAI's appeal on Friday, 13 November 2026, The Canadian Press and CBC News reported. The ruling leaves in place a decision of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice that it has jurisdiction to hear the copyright lawsuit brought by a group of Canadian news organizations, so the case can now move toward the merits in Ontario.

OpenAI had challenged where the case is heard, not yet whether it infringed. It argued that the dispute belongs in a US court. The Superior Court rejected that in its 2025 decision, cited as 2025 ONSC 6217, finding that several OpenAI entities carry on business in Ontario, and the appeal court upheld the ruling. According to The Canadian Press, the appeal court noted that OpenAI had not filed any evidence that a Canadian judgment would conflict with US law in a way that would complicate enforcing it.

The plaintiffs are the Toronto Star, Metroland Media, Postmedia, PNI Maritimes, The Globe and Mail, The Canadian Press and CBC/Radio-Canada. They filed the suit in November 2024, alleging that OpenAI copied their articles to train ChatGPT without permission or payment. The Canadian Press describes it as the first Canadian case to address the use of copyrighted content to train generative AI systems.

Why the forum matters

The jurisdiction fight is about which copyright law and which defences apply. In the United States, OpenAI's main defence in the consolidated New York Times and authors cases is fair use, and the US Justice Department filed a statement in September arguing that training large language models is fair use. Canada has a narrower fair dealing exception, limited to listed purposes such as research, private study, news reporting, criticism and review. Keeping the case in Ontario means a Canadian court will decide how that framework applies to model training.

The ruling also matters for other AI developers that serve Canadian users from abroad. If collecting data from Canadian websites, training models on it and selling access to Canadians is enough to bring a foreign company before an Ontario court, publishers have a home forum for similar claims. Canadian publishers including the Toronto Star have filed a separate lawsuit against Toronto based Cohere, and courts elsewhere are weighing related questions, from the Third Circuit's fair use ruling in the United States to the EU press publishers' right.

What happens next

No court has yet ruled on whether OpenAI's use of the articles infringed Canadian copyright or was covered by fair dealing. The reports do not give a trial date, and OpenAI's response to the decision was not stated in the coverage reviewed for this story. OpenAI could seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada; whether it will has not been announced.

Once the jurisdiction question is settled, the case returns to the Superior Court for the steps that come before a trial, such as document production and evidence on how the articles were collected and used. Those steps are where questions like which OpenAI entities trained which models, and on what data, are likely to be argued. The outcome will be one of the first answers from a Canadian court on whether training a commercial AI model on news articles needs a licence. More court and regulatory news is on the AI policy hub.

What changed

BeforeOpenAI was appealing the Ontario Superior Court's ruling that it has jurisdiction over the Canadian publishers' copyright suit
AfterThe Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed the appeal on 13 November 2026; the case can proceed in Ontario
Who it affectsOpenAI, Canadian news publishers, and AI developers that train on or serve Canadian content from abroad

Questions people ask

Can Canadian publishers sue OpenAI in Canada?
Yes. On 13 November 2026 the Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed OpenAI's appeal against a ruling that Ontario courts have jurisdiction, so the publishers' copyright case can proceed there.
Who is suing OpenAI in Canada?
The Toronto Star, Metroland Media, Postmedia, PNI Maritimes, The Globe and Mail, The Canadian Press and CBC/Radio-Canada, who filed the suit in November 2024.
Did the court decide that OpenAI infringed copyright?
No. The appeal only concerned where the case is heard. Whether training ChatGPT on the articles infringed Canadian copyright is still to be decided.

Sources

  1. Court of Appeal for Ontario, decisions (Court of Appeal for Ontario, 13 Nov 2026)
  2. Court allows news publishers' copyright lawsuit against OpenAI to go ahead (The Canadian Press via CP24, 13 Nov 2026)
  3. Lawsuit by Canadian news publishers against OpenAI gets green light to proceed in Ontario (CBC News, 13 Nov 2026)
  4. Ontario court rejects OpenAI appeal in Canadian media lawsuit (Broadcast Dialogue, 13 Nov 2026)

Reference pages

Spotted an error? See the corrections policy and tell the editor. Facts in this story come from the sources listed above; vendor claims are attributed.

Comments

Loading comments.

No links, no insults; comments that break the rules are not published. 0/1000